The New York Times and several other news organizations have filed lawsuits against Brave Software, the company behind the Brave web browser, accusing it of illegally scraping content to train artificial intelligence models and enabling users to circumvent paywalls. The legal action, which includes complaints from the New York Daily News, Chicago Tribune, and Orlando Sentinel, alleges that Brave has profited from scraped website data by selling access to AI companies while simultaneously undermining publishers' revenue through paywall-blocking features. According to the complaint, Brave has provided what publishers call "stolen copyrighted content" to multiple AI companies including Anthropic, Perplexity, Mistral, xAI, and Cohere.
The publishers' complaint centers on Brave's monetization of its web index, which the company has allegedly sold to AI developers as paid access to "real-time online content from the Brave Index." These AI firms then use the index either to train their models, access material to answer user questions, or both. Brave also advertises a "Paywall blocker" feature in its browser that promotes access to "hundreds of top publishers," the complaint states. The lawsuit alleges Brave never sought permission from publishers to access their sites, copy their material, or distribute it to users and other AI companies, nor has Brave compensated publishers for what they characterize as unlawful use of copyrighted content.
"While we believe in the ethical and responsible use and development of AI, Brave has flouted established copyright law," Graham James, a New York Times spokesperson, said in a statement. According to the complaint, Brave has taken steps that prevent publishers from blocking the browser's access to their websites and allows users to bypass paywalls without consent. Steven Lieberman, the attorney representing the New York Daily News, Chicago Tribune, and Orlando Sentinel, characterized Brave as "selling them a back door to the journalism they know they have no right to," arguing that "buying stolen goods secondhand doesn't make them legitimate."
The lawsuit reflects a broader tension between AI companies seeking training data and content creators asserting copyright protections. Publishers argue that Brave has created a workaround that allows AI companies to avoid direct scraping while still accessing copyrighted material through a third-party index. By positioning itself as an intermediary, Brave has allegedly enabled major AI developers to obtain news content without negotiating licensing agreements or facing the reputational risk of being "caught red-handed stealing news from publishers," as Lieberman put it. The Times filed its lawsuit "to hold Brave accountable for stealing our content to power its own products and to provide it to some of the most prominent and well resourced generative AI companies in the world," according to James.
The legal action seeks to establish accountability for what publishers view as both direct infringement and facilitation of copyright violations by AI companies. Most of the named AI companies did not respond to requests for comment, though Perplexity's chief communications officer dismissed the lawsuit as containing "disinformation." The outcome could set precedent for how browsers and search indexes are treated under copyright law when they provide scraped content to AI developers, potentially forcing technology companies to negotiate formal licensing deals with content creators rather than relying on intermediary data providers. The collision between browser functionality and publisher business models may ultimately require courts to define where technical capability ends and legal liability begins.

