Technology companies are meeting the bare minimum requirements of the UK's Online Safety Act but failing to protect the individuals and young victims the legislation was designed to help, according to experts who testified before Parliament's Communications and Digital Committee this week. Google, Microsoft, Meta, and ByteDance came under fire for inconsistent enforcement and declining responsiveness to harm reports. The hearing highlighted a growing frustration that more than a year after the law took effect, its real-world impact remains minimal.

Data from domestic violence charity Refuge shows the success rate for content-takedown requests plummeted from 53.7 percent before November 2025 to just 18.2 percent over the past 12 months. Meta's performance was even worse: since November 2025, zero percent of reports submitted to the platform through Refuge's Trusted Flagger team have been successful. Clare McGlynn, a professor of law at Durham University, pointed to major search engines' haphazard downranking of harmful search terms as evidence of inconsistent enforcement. While "rape porn" doesn't appear until the tenth page of Google results, similar terms like "unwilling porn" show up as early as the third page, and "forced porn" isn't downranked despite "force porn" being heavily suppressed.

McGlynn, who specializes in violence against women and girls, told the committee that platforms have the algorithmic capability to systematically downrank adjacent harmful terms like "unwilling," "unwanted," and "asleep porn," but simply aren't doing it. She also noted that pornography sites continue hosting extreme content legally to serve less-regulated regions, making it accessible to UK users via VPN connections that bypass age verification systems. Alexandra Whiston-Dew, a partner at law firm Miscon de Raya, said websites that openly advertise themselves as hosts of illegal content are slipping through search engines' enforcement entirely, and that regulator Ofcom lacks sufficient resources to tackle the problem alone.

The collapse in platform responsiveness raises questions about whether companies view compliance as a public relations exercise rather than a genuine commitment to user safety. Janaya Walker, interim director at the End Violence Against Women Coalition, expressed serious concern about how platforms behave under existing regulation, especially without a dedicated online commission to advocate for survivors' interests. McGlynn pointed to British Columbia's swift online civil redress system as a model other jurisdictions should follow, where individuals can obtain instant orders for content removal and even compensation for harm suffered. In contrast, UK victims still lack the legal right to demand an image be taken down or bring direct action against platforms or perpetrators. Companies like Google, Microsoft, and ByteDance face mounting pressure to demonstrate that their enforcement systems are more than performative gestures that fade once regulatory scrutiny lessens. The regulatory framework itself may need stronger enforcement teeth if platforms continue to treat compliance as optional once initial attention wanes.