The European Consumer Organisation (BEUC) has told Brussels that the world's largest technology companies are still violating the EU's Digital Markets Act (DMA) far too frequently for consumers to gain genuine choice over their digital services and products. The organization published its latest analysis drawing together evidence of potential breaches submitted to the European Commission between June 2025 and June 2026, targeting Alphabet, Amazon, Apple, ByteDance, Meta, and Microsoft — all designated as gatekeepers under the DMA. The report argues that Big Tech's adherence to the regulation remains superficial, leaving users without meaningful control over their digital experiences.

BEUC's analysis highlights specific violations across the six gatekeeper companies. Microsoft stands accused of deploying behavioral techniques and non-neutral interfaces to secure user consent for data sharing across its services, emphasizing advantages while failing to explain why someone might want to refuse. The company also allegedly makes it difficult to alter default settings and prevent actions like apps launching links in Edge or employing Bing as a search engine, with increasingly subtle prompts encouraging users to abandon alternative browsers or search engines. Google faced a €890 million fine in July for giving preference to its own services in Search and limiting developers' ability to steer Play Store users toward alternative payment options. Apple, ByteDance, Amazon, and Meta also feature in the report, with examples ranging from Apple's constraints on alternative app distribution to Amazon using interface design tactics to encourage users to surrender their data.

"The era of cosmetic compliance must end," BEUC director general Agustín Reyna stated in the report. "It is high time the Commission holds gatekeepers to account and imposes dissuasive penalties in all cases where they bypass the DMA's rules." The organization expressed concern that Apple's new developer terms announced earlier this year in response to its App Store dispute with the European Commission don't resolve fundamental non-compliance problems. When The Register requested comment, a Microsoft spokesperson said the company is continuing to work with the Commission and industry partners to ensure full DMA compliance, while Amazon defended its consent experience as clear and informed, noting that sellers using Amazon Stores in the EU can offer identical products on any third-party marketplace at any price without affecting their Featured Offer eligibility.

The Digital Markets Act aims to make digital markets fairer and more competitive by imposing obligations on core platform services like search engines, messaging apps, and app stores. The European Commission designated the six companies as gatekeepers in 2023, and has since expanded that designation to include Amazon and Microsoft's cloud operations. In March 2025, the Commission issued preliminary findings against Alphabet over Search and Google Play, while separately specifying measures Apple had to take to meet interoperability requirements. BEUC previously published a report on the DMA's consumer benefits in 2025, but its latest analysis shows the gap between regulatory intent and industry execution remains wide, with gatekeepers allegedly using consent language, default settings, and interface design to maintain control over user behavior.

BEUC has shared the report with the European Commission, and whether the allegations result in additional findings of non-compliance or penalties now rests with the regulator. The organization is pushing Brussels to impose tougher penalties for alleged barriers to switching services and controlling personal data, arguing that the current enforcement approach allows gatekeepers to bypass the DMA's rules without facing sufficiently dissuasive consequences. The Commission's response will signal whether Europe's flagship competition law can deliver on its promise of genuine digital choice or remains vulnerable to what BEUC calls "cosmetic compliance." The challenge for regulators isn't simply defining fair market practices on paper but enforcing them against companies whose business models depend on the very behaviors the law seeks to restrict.